MLB / Debates / The Yankees SHOULD NOT retire Paul O'Neill's #21 or Bernie Williams' #51

Create MLB

Webcam_16x16

Video Debate »

A FanVsFan Challenge is a structured debate between two fans. Each fan gets two turns to prove their case and silence their rival. Other fans can view, vote and comment on the debate. Create a Challenge to start a web-cam debate, take the opposing view on an open debate or get involved by voting and or commenting on this challenge. Do you agree or disagree with the below statement in green?



Initial Claim: The Yankees SHOULD NOT retire Paul O'Neill's #21 or Bernie Williams' #51 Bookmark and Share

MLB

Time Remaining Time's up
Winner

Should This Challenge Be a Fanbowl™?

Activity_meter_hot Share to increase chances.

Round 1

Supporting Fancast

This is the fancast that started the claim

Report this fancast | Recorded over 3 years

Opposing Fancast

Jeter?Thats a joke

Report this fancast | Recorded over 3 years

Round 2

Supporting Fancast

pot, meet kettle.

Report this fancast | Recorded over 3 years

Opposing Fancast

Cowards

Report this fancast | Recorded over 3 years

Challenge Comments

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

Dude the Yankees Suck the last couple of years period I mean damn you got smoked by the DEVIL RAYS Bro!..PFFFFD..Please…The Devil Rays, and retiring numbers what a joke. Who gives a shit about retiring numbers it’s a team sport dude!…but i’ll let you guys have your pissing match but Dude the DEVIL RAYS a EXPANSION team come on!
D. Jeter is a clutch player, but has no power and is a scrony whimp!, DEVIL RAYS is all I have too say the mighty evil Empire(26 WS titles) got smoke by a Expansion team!…You guys will not win the East for a long time period! that’s like getting beat by the Houston Texans for the Division title! what a joke your franchise is, headed a downward spiral. As long as A-Fraud is on your team your not winning SQUAT!. He chokes big time, 25+ million a year is crazy, what a waste of big time cash!

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

dunnn duh dunna duh daddaa dunn “Start spreading the news…dunnn duh dunna duh dadda PUKE YORKPUKE YORK

LOL how you like my typing singing! I hate that song and the Yankees!

Rossnicknydailynewscom_normal
NYYSI posted over 3 years ago

I swear, some of the people on this site are cartoon characters. Perfectly marketable, but I feel like I am in the twilight zone sometimes. Funny stuff!

Verb_normal
verb posted over 3 years ago

Really? You are going to bring up a Tiger stripped thong as part of this arguement.

Toilet_normal
Grogan14 posted over 3 years ago

As Far as Jim Rice goes….ill tell you whats different….steroids my friend, the SAME STEROIDS THAT WERE ON YOUR WS TEAMS!!!!!!!!!!!!! FACT!!!!!!!!!!!!

Toilet_normal
Grogan14 posted over 3 years ago

As Far as Jim Rice goes….ill tell you whats different….steroids my friend, the SAME STEROIDS THAT WERE ON YOUR WS TEAMS!!!!!!!!!!!!! FACT!!!!!!!!!!!!

Rossnicknydailynewscom_normal
NYYSI posted over 3 years ago

There is no record of Derek Jeter partaking in Jason Giambi’s golden thong ritual.

As for the spiked hair, thats just bed hair after taking care of business with the girlfriend.

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

I doubt that, does your girlfriend require AIR? Thhhhhhheeee Yankees suck! Get beat down by the Devil Rays explain that one!.

Toilet_normal
Grogan14 posted over 3 years ago

“There is no record of Derek Jeter partaking in Jason Giambi’s golden thong ritual. "

there isnt? UMMMMM Yes there is…copy link

http://www.nydailynews.com/gossip/2008/05/16/2008-05-16_jason_giambi_and_his_magic_gold_thong.html

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!! THE CAPTAIN OF YOUR TEAM WEARS A GOLDEN THONG!!!!!!! BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Toilet_normal
Grogan14 posted over 3 years ago

Or this one…..

http://www.cbssports.com/mlb/story/10830937

Default_avatar_normal
nick2slick posted over 3 years ago

Some classy Red Sox fans on here. NOT.

Rossnicknydailynewscom_normal
NYYSI posted over 3 years ago

OK, so Derek Jeter wore a golden thong.

However, he also is banging Minka Kelly, so he is forgiven.

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

Perfectly marketable!…nice phrase you use!.-NOT- if that’s intended as a insult then you got to do better than that..I hate the Yankees, and dislike the Redsox, So if your going to be a stereotype SHEEP, I thought I clear it up I’m a A’s Fan!, Now go take care of business with your girlfriend that require’s AIR. come with some substance insults not something a geek would say!, oh I am sorry that’s what you are huh? a GEEK!

Rossnicknydailynewscom_normal
NYYSI posted over 3 years ago

Nice, I’ll play the role of geek, as long as you play the role of uneducated typical Bay Area sports fan. Deal?

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

There you go again being a stereotype geek that knows nothing about sports all you know is your Yankees and tell me geek how does it feel to lose to the Devil Rays huh? You still haven’t answered that one your team will not win squat for a long time. Come with substance insults not the generic sheep bay area uneducated rant, like that hasn’t been said before I want to hear you say something original, but your brain isn’t capable of that huh? Thhhhhheeeee Yankees LOSE to the Devil Rays hahahahahahaha what a disgrace!

Rossnicknydailynewscom_normal
NYYSI posted over 3 years ago

Being that you continue to refer to the Rays as the Devil Rays, you are obviously ignorant to contemporary MLB team names. I can’t have a reasonable, educated debate with someone who doesn’t even recognize when a team changes its name. :)

As for “substance insults,” my style is not to insult. My style is to observe and comment. From reading around this site, I have learned that you are:

a) Uneducated when it comes to baseball and irrational when it comes to football
b) A Bay Area sports fan (at least Raiders and A’s)
c) Very abrasive, often times resorting to personal insults.

I’m still not sure whether you and Tito were planted here by FanvsFan for marketing purposes to rev up the engines of this site. Seriously, read through some of your debates, you are like caricatures of typical sports fans for the teams that you root for.

Toilet_normal
Grogan14 posted over 3 years ago

YANKEE GUY-
Your favorite team shares thong underwear-STRIKE ONE

You draw Smiley FACES ON YOUR TEXT- STRIKE TWO

We dont even need a strike three, because its clear your already “OUT”….hows your life partner doing?

Rossnicknydailynewscom_normal
NYYSI posted over 3 years ago

Don’t be mad that I helped to lower your already terrible 25.4% debate winning percentage.

You’re approaching the Mendoza line, BigTito – at what point are you forced into retirement?

Verb_normal
verb posted over 3 years ago

This is getting intense…Are any of you giving the Rays a chance of repeating?

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

If you had a brain stem which you don’t you would realize the voting system is flawed!….and you can disreguard records on this “beta testing” flawed website, plus looks like I got your panties on a not GEEK cause just see youong talk on your videos tells me I don’t have to break out any skills to get a rise out of you!. I can’t help you want to be ME!, and the funny thing you don’t know shot about me so say what ever your GEEK mind wants cause this is entertainment to see you resort to veague and basic responses you STILL can’t tell me what is up your Mighty Evil Empire losing to a expansion team for the divison title!. Cause your a Chump!, be a real not band wagon fan and explain why you lost to a EXPANSION team it’s a legit question that YOU and leech band wagon YANKEE Fans can’t answer cause your a shameful band wagon fan that has no BALLS!, I’m giving you facts your team lost to a expansion team period what do you got to say or spin or Marketable that GEEK?..I’m waiting and hear crickets, your a disgrace of a fan of a team that has tradition and make the fan base look like a bunch of PUSSIES! Cause that’s what you are! Prove me wrong band wagon fan!

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

Don’t worry about that…I already know your a BAND WAGON fan and are marketable!….dude your Yankees won’t win the east for a very long time!, and continue to get bitch slapped by the DEVIL RAYS and Red Sox for a long time!, I’ll bet your unemployment check that the Yankees finish 3rd or worst In the East, break that down I’m giving you a chance to prove you got a pair!

Rossnicknydailynewscom_normal
NYYSI posted over 3 years ago

At what point are the Rays not considered an expansion team anymore? You do realize that the Diamondbacks were introduced into MLB the same year as the Rays, but they won the World Series in 2001 (over my favorite team).

I do give the Rays a great chance in the AL East – it would be well-suited for another debate not related to this one.

Rossnicknydailynewscom_normal
NYYSI posted over 3 years ago

Is there some sort of homoerotic relationship between RaiderMike and Tito? I’m just wondering since I’m seeing a lot of defending of Tito by RaiderMike. Sorry, if I’m late to the party on this one…

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

whatever GEEK!

100_0361_normal
RaiderMike posted over 3 years ago

Hey don’t cry cause were too much for you to handle and if you could read as I said before I HATE THE YANKEES PERIOD, so you take it anyway your stereotype GEEK mind wants too, cause it’s funny too me to see a GEEK get pissed!…keep it coming GEEK!

You must be logged in leave a comment. Login or register now.