I looked at the title and I can't tell you how much I loved it.
Maybe It's because I HATE the Packers so much.
Let's see your boy A-rod do it again before you put him above one of the all time greats
Did you actually say Peyton Manning is not an elite Quarter back? Are you saying Aaron Rogers is better then Peyton Manning? Do you think before you talk? Aaron Roger's is 2011's Drew Brees. He will end up on the cover of Madden 12 and lose in the divisional playoffs next year.
acctually Drew Brees was the next Peyton Manning. In 2007 Peyton led his team to a super bowl win over chicago while the very next year losing in the divisional round to new england 3 to 20 while throwing no touchdowns and a pic atleast drews team put a fight...
Yeah, I don't agree with the saying of Manning is not an elite QB either, but I gave you the vote because I hate Rodgers and Da Pack.
I think the whole Rodgers is better than Peyton Manning is totally out of the box and wrong here. Look at Rodgers. The Packers got hot at the end of the season and rode the philly, atlanta, bears all on the road to the Super Bowl. Remind you of anything? When the Giants beat the Pats in 2007 they won all their road playoff games and got hot at the right time. There certainly was no talk of Eli being better than his brother or Brady for that matter and look what has happened since... Eli and the Giants are back in their place struggling at the end of seasons to get in and make noise. Until Rodgers shows he can get back into the playoffs and get to the NFC title game and consistently make the Pack a contender... Never will he be better than Brady or Manning.
Aaron Rodgers isnt as good as peyton manning looking at careers, but looking at the last three years, since Aaron has been a starter, peyton has thrown 93 tds and 45 int and has a play off record of 2 and 3 with no superbowls. Aaron has thrown for 86 tds and 31 int and has had a playoff record of 4 and 1. i doubt Aaron will have the career peyton has had but, he is better than peyton as of late.
Look at the talent Peyton has around him the last 3 years compared to Aaron Rodgers. Can you imagine what Manning would do if he had Driver and Jennings? Also Peyton made it to the Super Bowl last year he just didn't win it.
Peyton made the playoffs the last 3 seasons while Aaron hasn't
You must be logged in leave a comment.
A FanVsFan Challenge is a structured debate between two fans. Each fan gets two turns to prove their case and silence their rival. Other fans can view, vote and comment on the debate. Get involved and vote on the debates below.
See Full Leaderboard
Super Bowl XLIX: Why the Seahawks Will Remain the Champs
The Super Bowl NFL Standard w/Zlot and Yates
Scouting Report: David Cobb, Minnesota
Scouting Report: D'Joun Smith, FAU
College Gridiron Showcase Game Recap
Super Bowl XLIX: Good News/Bad News for New England Patriots